Skip to content
Oak Four

Everybody Has A Forecast

Posted by Kevin Wood

Every year, around this time, a ritual begins.

The big banks and fund houses publish their outlooks for the year ahead. They come with glossy covers, confident headlines and a precise number for where the stock market will finish next December.

They're interesting to read. Some are genuinely insightful.

But as a guide to what to do with your money, they have one big problem.

They're usually wrong.

The track record

The most watched forecast of all is where Wall Street's strategists expect the S&P 500, the index of America's 500 largest companies, to finish the year.

Here's how the average forecast compared with what actually happened:

  • 2025: forecast around 6,600, finished at 6,846 (4% too low)

  • 2024: forecast around 4,720, finished at 5,881 (25% too low)

  • 2023: forecast around 4,050, finished at 4,770 (18% too low)

  • 2022: forecast around 4,950, finished at 3,840 (22% too high)

  • 2021: forecast around 4,100, finished at 4,766 (16% too low)

  • 2020: forecast around 3,300, finished at 3,756 (14% too low)

In five of those six years, the consensus missed by 14% or more. In 2022, the year markets fell sharply, the experts expected a rise.

These aren't amateurs. They're some of the best-resourced analysts in the world, with teams of economists and oceans of data.

The problem isn't intelligence. It's that markets react to things nobody can see coming: a pandemic, a war, an election result, a sudden change of mood about a technology.

This month is a good example. Very few of this year's outlooks predicted the sharp fall in technology shares we wrote to you about recently. Yet within days, plenty of people were explaining exactly why it had happened.

Why forecasts are so tempting

We're wired to want certainty. A confident prediction feels more comforting than an honest "nobody knows".

Forecasts also give us a reason to act. And acting feels better than waiting, even when waiting is the wiser choice.

That's where the danger lies. A forecast on its own does no harm. The harm comes when someone moves their money because of it: selling before the crash that never arrives, or piling into the theme that's already peaked.

The whole story in two facts

The American writer and adviser Nick Murray makes a point I love: you can sum up the history of the stock market since the Second World War in two facts.

One: since 1945, the S&P 500 has returned an average of around 11.4% a year, with dividends reinvested.

Two: over the same period, it has fallen by an average of about 30% on 17 separate occasions. That's roughly once every five years.

Most people read those two facts as a contradiction: great returns, but painful falls.

The better reading is that they're the same fact. Investors have earned those returns because of the falls, not in spite of them. The market pays a premium precisely because it asks you to sit through the bad years. If shares never fell, nobody would need rewarding for owning them.

Seen that way, a fall like the one we've just had isn't a sign the plan is broken. It's the price of admission.

And no forecast tells you when that price will next be charged. As the investor Shelby Cullom Davis put it, "You make most of your money in a bear market; you just don't realize it at the time."

What actually drives your returns

If forecasting doesn't work, what does? The evidence points to a handful of things that are far less exciting, and far more reliable:

  • Owning the market, not guessing it. Spreading your money widely across companies, countries and types of investment means you don't need to know which part will do best. You'll own it anyway.

  • Keeping costs low. Every pound paid in fees is a pound that isn't compounding for you. Costs are one of the few things in investing you can control.

  • Rebalancing. Regularly bringing your portfolio back to its target mix makes you trim what's done well and top up what's lagged. It's a disciplined way of buying low and selling high without trying to predict anything.

  • Staying invested. Some of the market's best days tend to arrive close to its worst. Investors who step out to avoid the falls often miss the recovery too.

  • A plan that comes first. Your portfolio is built around your goals and timescales, not around anyone's view of next year. That's what lets you read the forecasts with interest, and then ignore them.

So, what's our forecast for 2027?

We don't have one.

Markets will probably have good months and bad months. There'll be headlines that make you nervous and headlines that tempt you to do more.

Over the long run, owning a broad spread of good businesses has rewarded patient investors. We don't expect that to change.

That's not a prediction. It's the reason we build plans the way we do.

If a headline ever leaves you wondering whether your plan still makes sense, give us a call. That's what we're here for.

This article is for information only and is not personal advice. The value of investments and the income from them can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than you invested. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.

Let’s start a conversation about your future

We offer a no obligation meeting to allow us to better understand you, your concerns and your life goals. Let’s get started on this journey together to get you ready for financial freedom.

Let's Get Started